🦪 The Best Oysters & Seafood in Key West – Did Your Favorite Make the List?

Hey Reader,

It’s Throwback Tuesday, and today we’re diving into a topic that’s near and dear to my heart (and stomach): the best oysters and seafood in Key West. Whether you’re a seasoned shucker or just here for the conch fritters, this list is your ultimate guide to the island’s freshest catches.

👉 Check out the full list here and see if your go-to spot made the cut!

Top Picks for Oysters & Seafood in Key West:

Half Shell Raw Bar: Located in the Historic Seaport, this spot boasts its own fish market, ensuring ultra-fresh seafood. Their oyster offerings range from classic raw to garlic cream and Rockefeller styles.
Thirsty Mermaid: A cozy spot on Fleming Street serving a rotating selection of East and West Coast oysters, plus a killer chipotle remoulade.
Alonzo’s Oyster Bar: Situated at the Aamp;B Marina, Alonzo’s offers a variety of oyster preparations, including baked combos and unique flavors like key lime garlic and buffalo.
Conch Republic Seafood Company: A local favorite in the Historic Seaport, known for its raw and steamed oysters, baked oysters with callaloo and parmesan, and the off-menu “Key West reds” when available.
Schooner Wharf: A laid-back spot on William Street offering oysters on the half shell, live music, and a twice-daily happy hour.

Whether you’re slurping oysters by the dozen or savoring a seafood platter, Key West has something to satisfy every seafood lover’s palate.

Have a favorite spot that’s not on the list? Hit reply and let me know—I’m always on the lookout for the next great seafood experience!

Until next Tuesday, stay salty and always keep it Key West-y. 🌴🦪

Cheers to fresh catches and ocean breezes,

Michele

Seafood Enthusiast & Oyster Aficionado

P.S. Don’t forget to pair those oysters with a crisp white wine or a cold beer—because life’s too short for bad pairings! 😉